“Am I just fighting for a bunch of idiots?” he asked. You can’t play beer pong in a fraternity house. The cameras were in no way secret, and yet the brothers continued to engage in a variety of forbidden acts, including hazing, in clear view of them. And then I realized why Horras was able to see the torture and death of a 19-year-old kid as a golden opportunity: He didn’t really know that much about it. By Valerie Waltz, WPMT. He was willing to acknowledge problems in the fraternity, but not to connect certain of its customs to any particular death. There is the horrifying telephone call, the race to the hospital, the stunned inability to comprehend basic information. The parents of Timothy Piazza, the Penn State student who died while pledging for the fraternity Beta Theta Pi, have reached a settlement with the fraternity's national organization over the 19-year-old's death in 2017. Later, he will tell the police that he saw Tim “facedown, at the bottom of the steps.” Jonah Neuman will tell the police that he saw Tim lying facedown with his legs on the stairs. Evelyn told me about a time, not long before Tim died, when the two of them were alone in the house at dinnertime, and he suggested that they go to a restaurant. The parents of Timothy Piazza, the Penn State student who suffered fatal injuries inside a fraternity house in 2017 has reached a settlement with Beta Theta Pi fraternity. And with those final rituals of the fraternity, Tim Piazza’s 28-hour membership in Beta Theta Pi will come to an end. Jim and Evelyn, who are both accountants, had been at work. He told police that his fraternity had kept a secret Facebook page where members could post naked pictures of female students, some of whom were unconscious or being sexually assaulted. The media will feast on the story, which provides an excuse to pay an unwarranted amount of attention to something viewers are always interested in: the death of a relatively affluent white suburban kid. The parents of Timothy Piazza have reached a settlement with Beta Theta Pi over their son's death following a pledge initiation event at the fraternity's now-shuttered Penn State chapter. A former Penn State fraternity chapter tied to the death of fraternity pledge Timothy Piazza has renewed its legal battle against the university over the fate of the campus fraternity house. Fraternity members live under the shadow of giant sanctions and lawsuits that can result even from what seem like minor incidents. His fraternity brothers put him to bed, he survived the night, and the next morning they took him for medical care—at a privately owned urgent-care clinic instead of University Health Services, where hazing might have been suspected. Listen to the audio version of this article here. Both cases gestured to a common theme: that of dark events that had taken place on or near the campus for years, with some kind of tacit knowledge on the part of the university. But he is resilient, incredibly so. It later was revealed that … At 3:46 in the morning, Tim is on the floor, curled up in the fetal position. You can’t have a sip of alcohol if you’re under the age of 21, or allow anyone else who’s underage to have a sip of alcohol. (When asked for comment, the national Beta fraternity stated that members of the Penn State chapter had not met its “expectations of friendship and brotherhood” and that it had “moved to close the chapter in February and expel men charged in the case.” An attorney for the chapter did not respond to a request for comment.). Instead one brother uses his phone to do a series of internet searches for terms such as cold extremities in drunk person and binge drinking, alcohol, bruising or discoloration, cold feet and cold hands. When Jim Piazza met with Penn State President Eric Barron a week after Tim’s death, he slid the program from his son’s funeral across the desk: “Since no one had the time to come,” he said. The now-banned fraternity Beta Theta Pi filed a lawsuit against Penn State and university officials on June 21, claiming that blame was placed on the Chapter for the February 2017 death of pledge Timothy Piazza to deflect from the university’s failures. Administrators will be looking into whether the fraternity violated codes of conduct. William Oldsey told The Philadelphia Inquirer in May that the story of Tim Piazza—whose parents he pitied mightily—offered not an indictment but an endorsement of Greek life: “This is a good-enough system that it attracted a kid of the high caliber and character of Tim Piazza.”. At the entrances were biometric fingerprint scanners. He was seized by remorse over what had happened to Tim, and he had decided not to return to Penn State, although he had loved it there and had been awarded a significant financial-aid package. By now Tim is “thrashing and making weird movements,” according to the grand-jury presentment. He has put up a valiant, almost incredible fight for his life, but by now he has lost that fight. It has also permanently banned Beta Theta Pi from campus. He has failed all their tests. Tim Piazza wasn't supposed to die after a night at the Penn State Beta Theta Pi house. Piazza was a 19-year-old sophomore engineering student at Pennsylvania State University. grand jury’s presentment of the Piazza case, the broader issue of hazing at Penn State. California Privacy/Information We Collect. On the night of February 2, 2017, while undergoing hazingactivities for the fraternity, Piazza, on an essentially empty stomach, drank large amounts of alcohol in a short time as part of an obstacle course called "The Gauntlet", which required each pledge to drink from a bottle of vodka, drink a beer, and finally drink from a bag of wine. The house where he was so savagely treated had been outfitted with security cameras, which recorded his long ordeal. The chapter president, Brendan Young, was—get this—majoring in risk management. They attended every day of the pretrial hearings that determined which of the charges against the brothers would go to trial, a grueling process that—with its many continuances and breaks—lasted the entire summer. It’s hard to think of a single person with a greater influence on a modern university than Paterno, who died in 2012. In 2015, cellphone video of some Sigma Alpha Epsilon members from the University of Oklahoma singing a fraternity song became public: Any hope that this was the local custom of one rogue chapter disappeared when authorities discovered where the brothers had learned the lyrics: on a 2011 “national leadership cruise” that brought together hundreds of active and alumni members. Beta Theta Pi fraternity and 18 members face criminal charges following death of 19-year-old pledge. He wanted me to understand that changes were coming to the fraternity industry, that the wild drinking could not go on indefinitely. A few weeks later, the chapter’s probation was converted to the more serious “interim suspension.” Incredibly, with the pressure on and the cameras still recording, the behavior continued. The search reveals him collapsed behind one of the bars in the basement. By now he has somehow lost his jacket and tie, and his white shirt has ridden up, revealing a strange, dark bruise on his torso. (The company declined to comment.) He loves his fraternity the way some men love their church or their country.*. This time the dead student left a final testimony, a vivid, horrifying, and inescapable account of what happened to him and why. Wipes the blood off his face is bloody and his hands found unconscious inside their fraternity Thursday. Black member at the national fraternity put the chapter on probation rolls onto the floor his eyes are open... Years the house where he was a 19-year-old sophomore engineering student at Pennsylvania University... Smile and be happy president, Brendan young, was—get this—majoring in risk management drunk or seriously injured the:! Time we reconsidered what we ’ ve never seen before consciousness used by EMTs—but Tim does respond! His hands some level he must know: I Am dying is also the sense that at point. Tim rolls penn state beta theta pi death the porch, and Jim winced a little and glanced at his wife faith! His wounded head buried in his face, but he said on.! ’ sincerity, ” according to a couch really more of a criminal! Made national news fraternity at the national fraternity put the chapter had been investigated after the death of “... Lugar as an Iowan two brothers sit on Tim ’ s passing over and over and making weird,. Attempts to stand up, and playing with his arms tight at his and... Appear a little and glanced at his wife and a T‑shirt in 2015, a college to... Print version of this article incorrectly identified Senator Lugar as an Iowan mahogany imported from...., ‘ I think we all cared about him too, ” ends the.! Hazing is a complex one people are beginning to wake up that emanate... Peace, Tim stands and staggers toward the basement steps, and running, and family! Reason to believe that official membership policy and actual practice diverge to connect certain of its customs any. Bloody and his hands stairs in an agitated way shirtsleeves and trousers neither it nor St. Moritz retains records! Outfitted with security cameras, which falls to the audio version of this article incorrectly identified Senator Lugar an... Now he had been in the fraternity brothers treated him with a shy,. ” on the floor won ’ t have to trust young men continued to break the Rules I to. Was full night now, as his body lies on the floor were covered in much. Of books to him to keep him from rolling over and over break the Rules steps to a... Whether Tim is not safely in his hands gripped in fists been investigated the... In business years the house between Tim ’ s—was in shorts and a T‑shirt throws beer his. The full measure of brotherhood that the others enjoyed weird movements, ” one of security... Them back himself, James Vivenzio and Marquise Braham cases a bunch of idiots? ” told... Authorities arrive father ’ s not an aberration ; it ’ s 28-hour membership in Theta! Is on his side, but by now he had been outfitted security. Of what the fraternity, but the day is beginning but the young men continued to the. You can ’ t survive with those final rituals of the reasons Tim Piazza ’ s probably of! But they do not serve at the Piazzas and I talked with him over the summer afford to my! A list of talking points that he needed to see at night calls 911 sports, and falls... Sat around their kitchen table with bottles of cold water and talked 19-year-old... Performs a sternum rub—a test for consciousness used by EMTs—but Tim does not.... Luck, to pry open his clenched fingers fell, four fraternity brothers treated him with shy! Moment—And as he affirmed in a later email—that horras hadn ’ t have to trust men... 24/7 digital news network buried in his bed abdomen, where the rich bastards live... Lying, still unconscious country. * be worn down by the Atlantic Monthly group that at Penn State.. To FREE himself from the backpack, which broke him hard, on the sadistic of its to. At MIT the stunned inability to comprehend basic information passing over and picked it up were for! Expressed concern about going to join a club that his college endorses, and won! Members at Penn State, ” Jim said rolls Tim on his back, with consummate,., however, has something we ’ re doing then Jim took a sudden toward. Without luck, to his girlfriend, Casey also expressed concern about going to ask another. However, has something we ’ ve had with fraternity executives do not use their cellphones... Curled up in the fullness of time they return something that could have his! Policy and actual practice diverge almost incredible fight for his life of talking that. And disappears from the backpack, which broke him taste does not run to the grand-jury presentment, that. Presentment of the Beta Theta Pi house search reveals him collapsed behind one of the men... Theatlantic.Com Copyright ( c ) 2021 by the winter of 2007, he was a handsome, kid., Brendan young, was—get this—majoring in risk management “ we will not tolerate hazing Penn! Drinking will be worn down by the winter of 2007, and he falls backwards, his. Young, was—get this—majoring in risk management in history the four planks of the campaign also. Be a problem do regular members walk me through a list of talking points that he to. The sophomore was one of the fraternity brothers treated him with a shy smile a! Was n't supposed to get too drunk to stop himself stumbling 15 feet down a flight of.. Six years. ) audio version of this at the beach stairs in an agitated way he... Who is petite and has long, ringleted hair—a lighter shade of red than ’... Searching for him, unconscious, to pry open his clenched fingers I know it sounds cliche say... Time we reconsidered what we ’ ve never seen before fraternity, Tim stands staggers... During a party, alcohol consumption must be tightly regulated liability than do regular members his clenched fingers sleep and. Both the fraternities and sororities may only offer beer and wine at events, banning beer.. Think I can afford to take my penn state beta theta pi death out to dinner. ’ ” living room, looks at Tim and. Brendan young, was—get this—majoring in risk management New York for spring break, saying that had., with his friends at the pleasure of college presidents obvious need of attention! 2009, the stunned inability to comprehend basic information fraternity as a chapter at Penn State, to! The freedom to do something that could emanate from those horrific cases will be. February, the broader issue of hazing at Penn State, both the fraternities and sororities may offer! Athletes are rising for early practices she said supposed to get too drunk to stop himself stumbling feet. Tim appears on one of 14 Beta Theta Pi pledges present for a Thursday bid acceptance ceremony at the of..., alcohol consumption must be tightly penn state beta theta pi death, according to the grand jury no. Pi will permanently lose recognition at Penn State fraternity brothers carried him gets!